NO Initial ITS Start location: l4 0: l0 -> l1 : y^0'=y^post0, x^0'=x^post0, z^0'=z^post0, (0 == 0 /\ y^0-x^0+x^post0 == 0 /\ y^0-y^post0 == 0), cost: 1 1: l0 -> l2 : y^0'=y^post1, x^0'=x^post1, z^0'=z^post1, (2-z^0 <= 0 /\ 1-z^0+z^post1 == 0 /\ -1-y^0+y^post1 == 0 /\ x^0-x^post1 == 0), cost: 1 3: l1 -> l0 : y^0'=y^post3, x^0'=x^post3, z^0'=z^post3, (-x^post3+x^0 == 0 /\ -y^post3+y^0 == 0 /\ -z^post3+z^0 == 0 /\ 2-x^0 <= 0), cost: 1 2: l2 -> l0 : y^0'=y^post2, x^0'=x^post2, z^0'=z^post2, (z^0-z^post2 == 0 /\ y^0-y^post2 == 0 /\ -x^post2+x^0 == 0), cost: 1 4: l3 -> l1 : y^0'=y^post4, x^0'=x^post4, z^0'=z^post4, (-x^post4+x^0 == 0 /\ -z^post4+z^0 == 0 /\ -y^post4+y^0 == 0), cost: 1 5: l4 -> l3 : y^0'=y^post5, x^0'=x^post5, z^0'=z^post5, (-x^post5+x^0 == 0 /\ -z^post5+z^0 == 0 /\ -y^post5+y^0 == 0), cost: 1 Applied preprocessing Original rule: l0 -> l1 : y^0'=y^post0, x^0'=x^post0, z^0'=z^post0, (0 == 0 /\ y^0-x^0+x^post0 == 0 /\ y^0-y^post0 == 0), cost: 1 New rule: l0 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, 0 == 0, cost: 1 Applied preprocessing Original rule: l0 -> l2 : y^0'=y^post1, x^0'=x^post1, z^0'=z^post1, (2-z^0 <= 0 /\ 1-z^0+z^post1 == 0 /\ -1-y^0+y^post1 == 0 /\ x^0-x^post1 == 0), cost: 1 New rule: l0 -> l2 : y^0'=1+y^0, z^0'=-1+z^0, -2+z^0 >= 0, cost: 1 Applied preprocessing Original rule: l2 -> l0 : y^0'=y^post2, x^0'=x^post2, z^0'=z^post2, (z^0-z^post2 == 0 /\ y^0-y^post2 == 0 /\ -x^post2+x^0 == 0), cost: 1 New rule: l2 -> l0 : TRUE, cost: 1 Applied preprocessing Original rule: l1 -> l0 : y^0'=y^post3, x^0'=x^post3, z^0'=z^post3, (-x^post3+x^0 == 0 /\ -y^post3+y^0 == 0 /\ -z^post3+z^0 == 0 /\ 2-x^0 <= 0), cost: 1 New rule: l1 -> l0 : -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 1 Applied preprocessing Original rule: l3 -> l1 : y^0'=y^post4, x^0'=x^post4, z^0'=z^post4, (-x^post4+x^0 == 0 /\ -z^post4+z^0 == 0 /\ -y^post4+y^0 == 0), cost: 1 New rule: l3 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 1 Applied preprocessing Original rule: l4 -> l3 : y^0'=y^post5, x^0'=x^post5, z^0'=z^post5, (-x^post5+x^0 == 0 /\ -z^post5+z^0 == 0 /\ -y^post5+y^0 == 0), cost: 1 New rule: l4 -> l3 : TRUE, cost: 1 Simplified rules Start location: l4 6: l0 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, 0 == 0, cost: 1 7: l0 -> l2 : y^0'=1+y^0, z^0'=-1+z^0, -2+z^0 >= 0, cost: 1 9: l1 -> l0 : -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 1 8: l2 -> l0 : TRUE, cost: 1 10: l3 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 1 11: l4 -> l3 : TRUE, cost: 1 Eliminating location l3 by chaining: Applied chaining First rule: l4 -> l3 : TRUE, cost: 1 Second rule: l3 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 1 New rule: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Applied deletion Removed the following rules: 10 11 Eliminating location l2 by chaining: Applied chaining First rule: l0 -> l2 : y^0'=1+y^0, z^0'=-1+z^0, -2+z^0 >= 0, cost: 1 Second rule: l2 -> l0 : TRUE, cost: 1 New rule: l0 -> l0 : y^0'=1+y^0, z^0'=-1+z^0, -2+z^0 >= 0, cost: 2 Applied deletion Removed the following rules: 7 8 Eliminated locations on linear paths Start location: l4 6: l0 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, 0 == 0, cost: 1 13: l0 -> l0 : y^0'=1+y^0, z^0'=-1+z^0, -2+z^0 >= 0, cost: 2 9: l1 -> l0 : -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 1 12: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Applied acceleration Original rule: l0 -> l0 : y^0'=1+y^0, z^0'=-1+z^0, -2+z^0 >= 0, cost: 2 New rule: l0 -> l0 : y^0'=y^0+n, z^0'=z^0-n, (-1+z^0-n >= 0 /\ n >= 0), cost: 2*n Sub-proof via acceration calculus written to file:///tmp/tmpnam_BJlenl.txt Applied instantiation Original rule: l0 -> l0 : y^0'=y^0+n, z^0'=z^0-n, (-1+z^0-n >= 0 /\ n >= 0), cost: 2*n New rule: l0 -> l0 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, z^0'=1, (0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: -2+2*z^0 Applied simplification Original rule: l0 -> l0 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, z^0'=1, (0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: -2+2*z^0 New rule: l0 -> l0 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, z^0'=1, -1+z^0 >= 0, cost: -2+2*z^0 Applied deletion Removed the following rules: 13 Accelerated simple loops Start location: l4 6: l0 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, 0 == 0, cost: 1 15: l0 -> l0 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, z^0'=1, -1+z^0 >= 0, cost: -2+2*z^0 9: l1 -> l0 : -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 1 12: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Applied chaining First rule: l1 -> l0 : -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 1 Second rule: l0 -> l0 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, z^0'=1, -1+z^0 >= 0, cost: -2+2*z^0 New rule: l1 -> l0 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, z^0'=1, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: -1+2*z^0 Applied deletion Removed the following rules: 15 Chained accelerated rules with incoming rules Start location: l4 6: l0 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, 0 == 0, cost: 1 9: l1 -> l0 : -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 1 16: l1 -> l0 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, z^0'=1, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: -1+2*z^0 12: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Eliminating location l0 by chaining: Applied chaining First rule: l1 -> l0 : -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 1 Second rule: l0 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, 0 == 0, cost: 1 New rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, (0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0), cost: 2 Applied simplification Original rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, (0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0), cost: 2 New rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 2 Applied chaining First rule: l1 -> l0 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, z^0'=1, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: -1+2*z^0 Second rule: l0 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, 0 == 0, cost: 1 New rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=1-y^0+x^0-z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: 2*z^0 Applied simplification Original rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=1-y^0+x^0-z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: 2*z^0 New rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=1-y^0+x^0-z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: 2*z^0 Applied deletion Removed the following rules: 6 9 16 Eliminated locations on tree-shaped paths Start location: l4 17: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 2 18: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=1-y^0+x^0-z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: 2*z^0 12: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Applied acceleration Original rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 2 New rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=x^0-y^0*n0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0*(-1+n0)+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: 2*n0 Sub-proof via acceration calculus written to file:///tmp/tmpnam_JBjChj.txt Applied nonterm Original rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 2 New rule: l1 -> [6] : (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ y^0 <= 0), cost: NONTERM Sub-proof via acceration calculus written to file:///tmp/tmpnam_gmlePl.txt Applied acceleration Original rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=1-y^0+x^0-z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: 2*z^0 New rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=y^0+n1*z^post0-n1, x^0'=-1/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0, z^0'=z^post0, (0 == 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: 2*n1*z^post0 Sub-proof via acceration calculus written to file:///tmp/tmpnam_DnACIN.txt Applied nonterm Original rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=1-y^0+x^0-z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: 2*z^0 New rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 <= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM Sub-proof via acceration calculus written to file:///tmp/tmpnam_gPKiGk.txt Applied chaining First rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=1-y^0+x^0-z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: 2*z^0 Second rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 2 New rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=2-2*y^0+x^0-2*z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: 2+2*z^0 Applied acceleration Original rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=2-2*y^0+x^0-2*z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: 2+2*z^0 New rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-n2+y^0+n2*z^post0, x^0'=n2-n2^2*z^post0-2*n2*y^0+x^0+n2^2-n2*z^post0, z^0'=z^post0, (0 == 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n2 >= 0), cost: 2*n2+2*n2*z^post0 Sub-proof via acceration calculus written to file:///tmp/tmpnam_bNfNLh.txt Applied nonterm Original rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=2-2*y^0+x^0-2*z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: 2+2*z^0 New rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 <= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM Sub-proof via acceration calculus written to file:///tmp/tmpnam_EcIPei.txt Applied chaining First rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 <= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 <= 0 /\ 0 == 0 /\ 1-z^post0 == 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0+x^0 >= 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^post0 == 0 /\ -1-2*y^0+x^0-z^post0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied chaining First rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=1-y^0+x^0-z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0), cost: 2*z^0 Second rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=x^0-y^0*n0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0*(-1+n0)+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: 2*n0 New rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=1-y^0-n0*(-1+y^0+z^0)+x^0-z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: 2*n0+2*z^0 Applied acceleration Original rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=1-y^0-n0*(-1+y^0+z^0)+x^0-z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: 2*n0+2*z^0 New rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-n4+y^0+n4*z^post0, x^0'=1/2*n4-1/2*n4^2*z^post0+1/2*n4*n0-n4*y^0-1/2*n4^2*n0*z^post0+x^0-1/2*n4*n0*z^post0-1/2*n4*z^post0+1/2*n4^2+1/2*n4^2*n0-n4*y^0*n0, z^0'=z^post0, (0 == 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^0)+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n4 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: 2*n4*n0+2*n4*z^post0 Sub-proof via acceration calculus written to file:///tmp/tmpnam_MFCkkp.txt Applied nonterm Original rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=-1+y^0+z^0, x^0'=1-y^0-n0*(-1+y^0+z^0)+x^0-z^0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: 2*n0+2*z^0 New rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 <= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^0)+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Sub-proof via acceration calculus written to file:///tmp/tmpnam_abAmdC.txt Applied chaining First rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=x^0-y^0*n0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0*(-1+n0)+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: 2*n0 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 <= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^0)+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 <= 0 /\ 0 == 0 /\ 1-z^post0 == 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^post0)+z^post0 == 0 /\ -2-y^0*(-1+n0)+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^post0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-y^0*n0-z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0-y^0*n0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied chaining First rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=y^0+n1*z^post0-n1, x^0'=-1/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0, z^0'=z^post0, (0 == 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: 2*n1*z^post0 New rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0-y^0*n1, z^0'=1, (y^0 == 0 /\ -2-y^0+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0), cost: 2+2*n1 Applied nonterm Original rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0-y^0*n1, z^0'=1, (y^0 == 0 /\ -2-y^0+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0), cost: 2+2*n1 New rule: l1 -> [6] : (y^0 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0+x^0 >= 0 /\ -y^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+n6 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Sub-proof via acceration calculus written to file:///tmp/tmpnam_HGFigH.txt Applied chaining First rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=y^0+n1*z^post0-n1, x^0'=-1/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0, z^0'=z^post0, (0 == 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: 2*n1*z^post0 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (y^0 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0+x^0 >= 0 /\ -y^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+n6 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 == 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ y^0+n1*z^post0-n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0 /\ -2-y^0-3/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+3/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0 >= 0 /\ -y^0-n1*z^post0+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+n6 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied chaining First rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=y^0+n1*z^post0-n1, x^0'=-1/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0, z^0'=z^post0, (0 == 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: 2*n1*z^post0 Second rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 2 New rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=y^0+n1*z^0-n1, x^0'=-y^0-3/2*n1*z^0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+3/2*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^0-y^0*n1, (-1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-1/2*n1*z^0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^0-y^0*n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: 2+2*n1*z^0 Applied nonterm Original rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=y^0+n1*z^0-n1, x^0'=-y^0-3/2*n1*z^0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+3/2*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^0-y^0*n1, (-1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-1/2*n1*z^0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^0-y^0*n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: 2+2*n1*z^0 New rule: l1 -> [6] : (1-y^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ 1-z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-1/2*n1*z^0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^0-y^0*n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 >= 0 /\ n7 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Sub-proof via acceration calculus written to file:///tmp/tmpnam_heiHGA.txt Applied chaining First rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=-y^0+x^0, z^0'=z^post0, -2+x^0 >= 0, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (1-y^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ 1-z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-1/2*n1*z^0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^0-y^0*n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 >= 0 /\ n7 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l1 -> [6] : (1-z^post0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ 1-y^0-z^post0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0-1/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0 >= 0 /\ n7 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^post0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied simplification Original rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=y^0+n1*z^post0-n1, x^0'=-1/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0, z^0'=z^post0, (0 == 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: 2*n1*z^post0 New rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=y^0+n1*z^post0-n1, x^0'=-1/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: 2*n1*z^post0 Applied simplification Original rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 <= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l1 -> [6] : (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM Applied simplification Original rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 <= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l1 -> [6] : (-1-y^0+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM Applied simplification Original rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 <= 0 /\ 0 == 0 /\ 1-z^post0 == 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0+x^0 >= 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^post0 == 0 /\ -1-2*y^0+x^0-z^post0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l1 -> [6] : (-1+z^post0 == 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^post0 == 0 /\ -1-2*y^0+x^0-z^post0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied simplification Original rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 <= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^0)+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l1 -> [6] : (-1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^0)+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied simplification Original rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 <= 0 /\ 0 == 0 /\ 1-z^post0 == 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^post0)+z^post0 == 0 /\ -2-y^0*(-1+n0)+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^post0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-y^0*n0-z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0-y^0*n0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l1 -> [6] : (-1+z^post0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^post0)+z^post0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0-y^0*n0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied simplification Original rule: l1 -> [6] : (0 == 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ y^0+n1*z^post0-n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0 /\ -2-y^0-3/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+3/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0 >= 0 /\ -y^0-n1*z^post0+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+n6 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l1 -> [6] : (-1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ y^0+n1*z^post0-n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0 /\ -2-y^0-3/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+3/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0 >= 0 /\ -y^0-n1*z^post0+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+n6 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied simplification Original rule: l1 -> [6] : (1-z^post0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ -2+x^0 >= 0 /\ 1-y^0-z^post0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0-1/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0 >= 0 /\ n7 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^post0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l1 -> [6] : (-1+z^post0 <= 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ 1-y^0-z^post0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0-1/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0 >= 0 /\ n7 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^post0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied deletion Removed the following rules: 17 18 Accelerated simple loops Start location: l4 19: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=x^0-y^0*n0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0*(-1+n0)+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: 2*n0 20: l1 -> [6] : (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ y^0 <= 0), cost: NONTERM 27: l1 -> [6] : (y^0 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0+x^0 >= 0 /\ -y^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+n6 >= 0), cost: NONTERM 29: l1 -> [6] : (1-y^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ 1-z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-1/2*n1*z^0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^0-y^0*n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 >= 0 /\ n7 >= 0), cost: NONTERM 31: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=y^0+n1*z^post0-n1, x^0'=-1/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: 2*n1*z^post0 32: l1 -> [6] : (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM 33: l1 -> [6] : (-1-y^0+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM 34: l1 -> [6] : (-1+z^post0 == 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^post0 == 0 /\ -1-2*y^0+x^0-z^post0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM 35: l1 -> [6] : (-1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^0)+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM 36: l1 -> [6] : (-1+z^post0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^post0)+z^post0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0-y^0*n0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM 37: l1 -> [6] : (-1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ y^0+n1*z^post0-n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0 /\ -2-y^0-3/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+3/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0 >= 0 /\ -y^0-n1*z^post0+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+n6 >= 0), cost: NONTERM 38: l1 -> [6] : (-1+z^post0 <= 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ 1-y^0-z^post0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0-1/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0 >= 0 /\ n7 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^post0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM 12: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Applied chaining First rule: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> l1 : x^0'=x^0-y^0*n0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0*(-1+n0)+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: 2*n0 New rule: l4 -> l1 : x^0'=x^0-y^0*n0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0*(-1+n0)+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: 2+2*n0 Applied chaining First rule: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ y^0 <= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l4 -> [6] : (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ y^0 <= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied chaining First rule: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (y^0 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0+x^0 >= 0 /\ -y^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+n6 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l4 -> [6] : (-2-y^0+x^0 >= 0 /\ -y^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM Applied chaining First rule: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (1-y^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ 1-z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-1/2*n1*z^0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^0-y^0*n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 >= 0 /\ n7 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l4 -> [6] : (-1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-1/2*n1*z^0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^0-y^0*n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM Applied chaining First rule: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> l1 : y^0'=y^0+n1*z^post0-n1, x^0'=-1/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: 2*n1*z^post0 New rule: l4 -> l1 : y^0'=y^0+n1*z^0-n1, x^0'=-1/2*n1*z^0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^0-y^0*n1, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: 2+2*n1*z^0 Applied chaining First rule: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ -1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l4 -> [6] : (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM Applied chaining First rule: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (-1-y^0+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l4 -> [6] : (-1-y^0+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM Applied chaining First rule: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (-1+z^post0 == 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^post0 == 0 /\ -1-2*y^0+x^0-z^post0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l4 -> [6] : (y^0 == 0 /\ -2-2*y^0+x^0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied chaining First rule: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (-1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ z^0-z^post0 == 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^0)+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l4 -> [6] : (-1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^0)+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied chaining First rule: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (-1+z^post0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^post0)+z^post0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0-y^0*n0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l4 -> [6] : (y^0+y^0*n0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0-y^0*n0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied chaining First rule: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (-1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ y^0+n1*z^post0-n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0 /\ -2-y^0-3/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+3/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0 >= 0 /\ -y^0-n1*z^post0+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+n6 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l4 -> [6] : (-1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0 /\ -2-y^0-3/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+3/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0 >= 0 /\ -y^0-n1*z^post0+n1 == 0), cost: NONTERM Applied chaining First rule: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 Second rule: l1 -> [6] : (-1+z^post0 <= 0 /\ -1+z^post0 >= 0 /\ 1-y^0-z^post0 >= 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0-1/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0 >= 0 /\ n7 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^post0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM New rule: l4 -> [6] : (y^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0+x^0-y^0*n1 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Applied deletion Removed the following rules: 19 20 27 29 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 Chained accelerated rules with incoming rules Start location: l4 12: l4 -> l1 : TRUE, cost: 2 39: l4 -> l1 : x^0'=x^0-y^0*n0, z^0'=z^post0, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0*(-1+n0)+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: 2+2*n0 40: l4 -> [6] : (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ y^0 <= 0), cost: NONTERM 41: l4 -> [6] : (-2-y^0+x^0 >= 0 /\ -y^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM 42: l4 -> [6] : (-1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-1/2*n1*z^0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^0-y^0*n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM 43: l4 -> l1 : y^0'=y^0+n1*z^0-n1, x^0'=-1/2*n1*z^0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^0-y^0*n1, (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: 2+2*n1*z^0 44: l4 -> [6] : (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM 45: l4 -> [6] : (-1-y^0+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM 46: l4 -> [6] : (y^0 == 0 /\ -2-2*y^0+x^0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM 47: l4 -> [6] : (-1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^0)+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM 48: l4 -> [6] : (y^0+y^0*n0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0-y^0*n0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM 49: l4 -> [6] : (-1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0 /\ -2-y^0-3/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+3/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0 >= 0 /\ -y^0-n1*z^post0+n1 == 0), cost: NONTERM 50: l4 -> [6] : (y^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0+x^0-y^0*n1 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Removed unreachable locations and irrelevant leafs Start location: l4 40: l4 -> [6] : (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ y^0 <= 0), cost: NONTERM 41: l4 -> [6] : (-2-y^0+x^0 >= 0 /\ -y^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM 42: l4 -> [6] : (-1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-1/2*n1*z^0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+1/2*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^0-y^0*n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM 44: l4 -> [6] : (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ -1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM 45: l4 -> [6] : (-1-y^0+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -2+2*y^0+2*z^0 == 0), cost: NONTERM 46: l4 -> [6] : (y^0 == 0 /\ -2-2*y^0+x^0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM 47: l4 -> [6] : (-1-y^0-(-1+y^0+z^0)*(-1+n0)+x^0-z^0 >= 0 /\ 1-z^0 == 0 /\ -1+y^0+n0*(-1+y^0+z^0)+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM 48: l4 -> [6] : (y^0+y^0*n0 == 0 /\ -2+x^0-y^0*n0 >= 0 /\ -1+n0 >= 0), cost: NONTERM 49: l4 -> [6] : (-1+z^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -1+y^0+z^0 == 0 /\ -2-y^0-3/2*n1*z^post0+x^0+1/2*n1^2+3/2*n1-y^0*n1-1/2*n1^2*z^post0 >= 0 /\ -y^0-n1*z^post0+n1 == 0), cost: NONTERM 50: l4 -> [6] : (y^0 == 0 /\ -1+n1 >= 0 /\ -2-y^0+x^0-y^0*n1 >= 0), cost: NONTERM Computing asymptotic complexity Proved nontermination of rule 40 via SMT. Proved the following lower bound Complexity: Nonterm Cpx degree: Nonterm Solved cost: NONTERM Rule cost: NONTERM Rule guard: (-2+x^0 >= 0 /\ y^0 <= 0)